5
Calling all meat lovers! I’m here to share the top restaurants in NYC for carnivores. From juicy burgers to succulent steaks, I’ve got you covered.
New York City is a paradise for meat lovers. From sizzling steaks to perfectly grilled chops, this city has it all. As someone who’s tasted my way through the best, I’m here to guide you to the top spots for carnivores.
Since incorporating more “carnivore” in my diet, I’ve spent countless nights exploring NYC’s meat scene. These places are where you’ll find the juiciest cuts and the most flavorful dishes. Trust me, these restaurants are the real deal during your stay in New York City!
Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these are the must-eat spots for any meat eater. Let’s dive into the best restaurants in NYC for meat eaters.
Best places to eat in NYC for carnivores
Before we dive into the list, here are some of my top picks to get you excited:
- Best overall steakhouse: Peter Luger Steak House
- Best modern vibe: Quality Meats
- Most unique experience: COTE Korean Steakhouse
- Best for casual eats: Dickson’s Farmstand Meats
- Best classic experience: Delmonico’s
Now, let’s jump into the detailed list of the best restaurants for meat eaters in New York, starting with Rocco Steakhouse.
1. Rocco Steakhouse
Rocco Steakhouse on Madison Ave. is a gem in New York City for meat lovers. It perfectly blends the charm of an old-school steakhouse with the warmth of a family-run business.
When I visited, I tried the New York Sirloin Steak and Lamb Chops. Both were exceptional. The steaks are aged to perfection, with just the right amount of marbling. The lamb chops were tender and full of flavor. The decor is modern and refreshing, a nice change from the typical steakhouse look.
One thing that stood out was the service. The experienced waiters know their stuff, even tilting plates to drain extra oil from the steak. The plates come out super hot, keeping your meal just the right temperature. The wine selection is impressive, too, and pairs perfectly with the rich, juicy steaks.
Rocco Steakhouse is spacious and fun, but be prepared for a bit of a wait—it’s popular for a reason! Trust me, the wait is worth it. It’s the best steak I’ve had in Manhattan, and everyone I was with was equally satisfied. If you’re looking for the best steakhouses in NYC, this place is a must-visit.
2. Hawksmoor
Hawksmoor at 109 E 22nd St is a carnivore’s dream. The ambiance is top-notch, and it’s perfect for a night out or a cozy dinner. The steaks are cooked to perfection, allowing the dry-aging process to shine.
I tried the bone-in rib chop, and it was incredible. They don’t overload it with butter, so you get the pure, rich flavor of the meat. My friend had the chateaubriand and beef fat fries, both of which were mouthwatering. The charred scallops and bone marrow are must-tries too.
One thing that stands out is the reasonable corkage fee of $35. I brought some of my favorite red wines, and they paired wonderfully with the meal. It’s a great way to enjoy your own wine without breaking the bank.
If you’re heading there, try to book an early reservation for the best selection of meat cuts. They also have a fantastic Sunday roast, which is perfect for a weekend treat. Hawksmoor is definitely one of the best restaurants for carnivores and one of the top things to do in New York City. Don’t miss it!
3. Quality Meats
If you’re hunting for the ultimate steak experience, Quality Meats on W 58th St is where you need to be. This place tops my list of favorite NYC steakhouses. The elegant and romantic atmosphere sets the perfect mood for an unforgettable meal.
Their steak selection is out of this world. I started with the bacon appetizer, which was not only delicious but also unique. The Porterhouse steak was a showstopper, perfectly aged and marbled, cooked just the way I like it. The cherry glaze added a delightful twist to the steak’s flavor.
Another highlight was the beef tartar. The hostess mixed the spices right at the table. The sides were all fantastic, complementing the main courses perfectly. The space itself is beautiful, combining modern design with a rustic twist. The dim lighting creates a cozy, intimate setting ideal for dinner.
Sure, top-tier steakhouses in Manhattan aren’t cheap, but trust me, Quality Meats is worth every penny. The service is impeccable, and the food is outstanding. For meat lovers, this place is a must, and one of the unique restaurants in New York City!
4. Blue Smoke
Craving some top-notch BBQ in NYC? Blue Smoke is the place to be. This restaurant, located in the heart of the financial district and World Trade Center area, serves up some of the best barbeque I’ve ever tasted.
The brisket at Blue Smoke is incredible. Perfectly seasoned, tender, and moist, it practically melts in your mouth. I also tried the Memphis Baby Back Ribs, which were mouthwatering and falling off the bone. Each dish was packed with flavor and cooked to perfection.
What I love most about Blue Smoke, besides the amazing food, is the service. The staff here are fantastic. They make you feel right at home from the moment you walk in. It’s a welcoming spot that’s perfect for a casual meal with friends or a relaxed night out.
If you’re a carnivore looking for the best BBQ in New York, Blue Smoke should be at the top of your list. It’s a fantastic spot with delicious food and outstanding service.
5. Peter Luger Steak House
If you love steak, I highly recommend a visit to Peter Luger Steak House at 178 Broadway. This place has been serving up the best steaks in NYC since 1887, and it’s easy to see why it’s a favorite.
Walking in, you instantly get that old-world steakhouse vibe. The service is top-notch, and the dry-aged steaks are always seared to perfection. Their famous 1/2 lb burger is also a hit, and I can personally vouch for its deliciousness!
During my visit, I was blown away by the quality and flavor of the steak. Peter Luger truly stands out among the best restaurants for carnivore diets in NYC. Even though it’s a popular spot for tourists, it never feels like a tourist trap. The food and atmosphere are simply unmatched.
Remember to bring cash or a US debit card since they don’t accept credit cards. Reservations are a good idea, but if you don’t have one, arriving early can help you snag a table. Peter Luger is worth every penny and every minute of the wait for meat lovers.
6. Balvanera
If you’re in NYC and craving Argentinian steak, Balvanera is the place to be! Located at 152 Stanton St, this restaurant offers a warm and elite atmosphere that sets the stage for a fantastic meal.
When I visited, I ordered the rib-eye. It was phenomenal. Perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of marbling, it was juicy and flavorful. I also tried the blood sausage (morcilla) and homemade chorizo. The blood sausage was a first for me, and I loved it! The chorizo was exquisite, bursting with flavor.
The trio of meats were perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. They had a beautiful char while remaining rare, just as I requested. The waitstaff were polite, welcoming, and made the experience even better.
Balvanera is spacious for the Lower East Side, and the noise level is just right. You can actually have a conversation without shouting, which is a huge plus. For anyone on a carnivore diet, Balvanera is one of the best restaurants in NYC to enjoy delicious Argentinian cooking.
7. COTE Korean Steakhouse
Looking for the best restaurants in NYC for meat eaters? Let me tell you about COTE Korean Steakhouse on W 22nd St. This place is carnivore’s paradise, blending Korean BBQ with a sleek, modern vibe that’s simply awesome.
Start with the Butcher’s Feast and add the A5 wagyu. Trust me, the meat here is top-notch. They even have their own dry-aging room, so every cut is perfect. The banchans, or side dishes, are a delicious bonus that rounds out the meal perfectly.
On my visit, I couldn’t get enough of the tuna tartare, oysters, Butcher’s Feast, and wagyu paella. Each dish was mouthwatering and left me wanting more. Honestly, it’s become my favorite KBBQ spot in the city.
For the full experience, sit indoors so you can watch the waiter cook the prime cuts of beef right at your table. It’s a fun, interactive part of the meal that you shouldn’t miss.
The ambiance at COTE is fantastic, and the service is spot-on. If you love meat, you’ve got to check this place out. It stands out in NYC’s dining scene and will leave you planning your next visit before you even leave.
8. Delmonico’s
Alright, let’s talk about Delmonico’s. If you haven’t been, you’re missing out on a true New York experience! This place has been a prime beef institution since 1837, and it’s every bit as legendary as you’ve heard.
The Delmonico steak is a game-changer. Perfectly dry-aged, with a sear that gives it a fantastic crispy crust. It’s juicy, full of flavor, and simply delicious. I always go for medium rare. It hits that sweet spot of tenderness and flavor without drying out.
Walking into Delmonico’s feels like stepping into New York history. The old-timey charm is unbeatable, and the five-star service makes you feel like royalty. Dress up a bit, because this place is special.
Sure, it’s on the pricey side, but it’s worth every penny. The ambiance, the impeccable service, and most importantly, the incredible food make it a spot to remember. Don’t forget to make a reservation. This iconic spot gets busy, and you don’t want to miss out.
For anyone on the hunt for the best places in NYC for carnivores, Delmonico’s is a legendary choice that lives up to the hype.
9. Club A
Ready for an unforgettable steak night? Head over to Club A on E 58th St! This place combines traditional steakhouse vibes with a splash of elegance, complete with a piano room and a wine cellar that sets the mood just right.
The steaks here are next-level. They’ve nailed the Maillard crust – crispy and aromatic on the outside, tender and juicy on the inside. My bone-in ribeye was a thick cut, cooked to perfection, and absolutely mouthwatering.
What makes Club A extra special is the personal touch. We were warmly greeted by the owner, Bruno, as we walked in. It’s rare to see an owner-operated spot these days. It really adds a cozy, welcoming vibe. The staff here are awesome – super helpful, knowledgeable, and friendly,
The ambiance is elegant yet comfortable, perfect for a special night out or just treating yourself to some fantastic food.
For those hunting down the best steak restaurants in NYC, Club A is a gem in New York you won’t want to miss. Enjoy the food, soak in the atmosphere, and you’ll see why it’s a favorite!
10. Carne Mare
When it comes to the best places to eat in NYC for meat eaters, Carne Mare at 89 South Street is a standout! Imagine this: mouthwatering food, fantastic vibes, and stunning views of the Brooklyn Bridge.
The moment we walked in, I knew it was going to be a great night. The warm atmosphere and killer music really set the scene. We went big and ordered the shared 40 oz Tomahawk and 45 oz Porterhouse steaks. Both were cooked to medium rare perfection—juicy, flavorful, and totally worth it.
What I love about Carne Mare is how everything comes together seamlessly. The service is top-notch, with staff that makes you feel welcome and taken care of. It’s a bit pricey, but for a special occasion, it’s perfect.
And those views! Dining with the Brooklyn Bridge as your backdrop adds an extra layer of magic to the experience. Carne Mare is one of those places where you’re already planning your next visit before you even leave. I promise, you’ll love every moment and every bite!
11. Dickson’s Farmstand Meats
Dickson’s Farmstand Meats in Chelsea Market is a meat lover’s paradise. The moment you step in, the incredible aroma of freshly cooked meats draws you in, and you know you’re in for something special.
I tried the brisket sandwich, and it was heavenly. Juicy meat, delicious BBQ sauce, and the perfect fried onions to top it off. Their burgers and other meats are just as incredible.
The staff at Dickson’s are super friendly and playful, adding to the enjoyable atmosphere. The kitchen and cooking areas are spotless, which always makes the experience even better. Plus, there are plenty of seats for both locals and tourists
And let’s talk about the drinks. There’s a bar where you can grab a drink to go with your meal. If you’re visiting Chelsea Market, Dickson’s Farmstand Meats is a must-try. It’s easily one of the best places to eat meat in NYC.
12. Boucherie West Village
Ever feel like dining in a cozy Parisian bistro without leaving NYC? Head to Boucherie West Village at 99 7th Ave S. This spot blends vintage charm with a warm, inviting atmosphere that makes you want to linger.
The interior is stunning, filled with lush plants and classic decor that give off those perfect French vibes. I tried the ribeye steak, and it was out-of-this-world delicious. It was juicy, tender, and cooked just the way I like it. The beef tartare and escargot are also top picks if you’re in the mood for something different.
The staff here are fantastic. They’re friendly, attentive, and make sure your dining experience is nothing short of amazing. It’s one of those places where you feel genuinely taken care of.
For meat lovers hunting down the best restaurants in New York City for carnivores, Boucherie West Village is a real gem. The combination of delicious food, beautiful ambiance, and top-notch service makes it a spot you’ll want to return to again and again!
Frequently asked questions (FAQs) about the best NYC restaurants for carnivores
Craving a carnivorous feast in NYC? Find all the answers you need about the best meat-centric restaurants in the Big Apple.
Where can I find the best steak in NYC?
For the best steak in NYC, check out Peter Luger Steak House in Brooklyn, renowned for its dry-aged porterhouse. Rocco Steakhouse and Quality Meats are top picks for a modern steak experience. For a unique twist, try COTE Korean Steakhouse with its premium Korean BBQ.
Is it possible to eat carnivore at NYC restaurants?
Yes, you can easily eat carnivore at NYC restaurants. Steakhouses like Peter Luger, Rocco Steakhouse, and Delmonico’s offer a variety of meat dishes. For a casual option, visit Dickson’s Farmstand Meats in Chelsea Market. Many places are happy to accommodate carnivore diet requests when traveling to New York City.
Is the carnivore diet healthy?
The carnivore diet can be healthy if done correctly, focusing on high-quality meats. It supports muscle growth and can help with weight management. However, consult with a healthcare provider before starting to make sure it meets your nutritional needs.
